As the healthcare industry evolves, hospitals are preparing to invest billions in artificial intelligence (AI) technologies. However, many find themselves ill-prepared to accurately assess the return on their investments. Leaders within health systems are still in the process of determining the most effective ways to gauge the success of AI applications, which range from clinical outcomes to staff satisfaction.
One of the main challenges faced by healthcare executives is establishing effective metrics to measure ROI. According to Kiran Mysore, Chief Data & Analytics Officer at Sutter Health, ‘The challenge we have today is most pilots don’t think about ROI upfront.’ The potential conversation about AI value must happen early in the process to ensure informed decision-making regarding investment size and strategy. If a hospital estimates a modest return on investment, it is unlikely to invest heavily, whereas promising a much higher ROI could draw a significant commitment.
AI-powered tools, particularly ambient listening devices, can ease the cognitive burden on clinicians, leading to improvements in job satisfaction and reduced stress levels. This is crucial, as the healthcare sector is experiencing a significant burnout crisis among clinicians. Mysore emphasizes the importance of measuring qualitative metrics, which can be just as significant as quantitative outcomes.
Scott Arnold, CIO of Tampa General Hospital, agrees with the importance of non-traditional ROI metrics. ‘There may not be a direct ROI that I can show the CFO, but I can point to the attrition rate and its correlation with job satisfaction and reduced workload thanks to AI tools,’ he noted.
Scaling AI Solutions and Challenges
As health systems transition their AI initiatives from pilot phases to comprehensive implementation, scalability remains a significant obstacle. Mysore notes that even if a pilot tool is successful, its application may differ across specialties. Individual roles, from primary care physicians to cardiologists, each have unique documentation and inquiry needs, complicating the scaling process.
Tej Shah, Managing Director at Accenture, points out that many health systems lack the necessary infrastructure for rapid AI scaling. ‘They’re investing to pilot these AI solutions but are not building the infrastructure needed to realize value,’ he indicated. To develop a robust infrastructure, hospitals must embrace digital transformation by migrating to cloud operations and ensuring quality data governance, enabling AI tools to produce dependable insights.
Moreover, staff training is essential in managing the transition to AI technologies. A focus on educating healthcare professionals on technology implementation will help ensure ethical use and maximize efficiency, improving overall care delivery.
Addressing the Evidence Gap in AI Tools
Another significant challenge is the lack of real-world evidence supporting the deployment of AI solutions in healthcare. Meg Barron, Managing Director at the Peterson Health Technology Institute, said, ‘Hospitals don’t have enough external evidence to reference which tools work best, hampering decision-making.’ The PHTI is working to publish public research that highlights the clinical and economic impacts of digital health tools. Barron emphasizes evaluating clinical effectiveness over user engagement and satisfaction, stating, ‘There can often be bias and a lack of quality in much of the research.’
AI in healthcare generates abundant opportunities, but providers must remain vigilant in examining both the efficacy and economic implications associated with these technologies. As Barron concludes, establishing rigorous evidence and transparent research standards will facilitate informed decisions and enable hospitals to invest wisely in AI technologies that enhance care.
In conclusion, as hospitals continue to invest heavily in AI, understanding ROI and addressing the accompanying challenges will be crucial for optimizing their technological journey and ultimately improving patient care.
- 0 Comments
- Data Governance
- Hospitals